📡 SDR Device Comparison

Complete SDR Hardware Guide for RFS-Portable-BTS

Compare BladeRF models and alternative SDR devices for IoT security testing. Make informed decisions about your portable GSM BTS hardware.

🎯 Recommended SDR: BladeRF Mini A4

📊 BladeRF Model Comparison

Specification Mini A4 x40 x115
Frequency Range 70MHz - 6GHz 70MHz - 6GHz 70MHz - 6GHz
Instantaneous Bandwidth 40MHz 40MHz 115MHz
Interface USB 3.0 USB 3.0 USB 3.0
Power Supply USB Powered External 12V External 12V
Size Compact Standard Large
Price Range $200-250 $400-500 $800-1000
Use Case IoT Security Testing Professional Testing Advanced Research
Portability Excellent Good Fair

🎯 BladeRF Mini A4 (Recommended)

📊 Technical Specifications

  • Frequency Range: 70MHz - 6GHz
  • Bandwidth: 40MHz instantaneous
  • Interface: USB 3.0 SuperSpeed
  • Power: USB powered (5V/1A)
  • Size: 100mm x 60mm x 15mm
  • Weight: 50g
  • Operating Temperature: -10°C to +70°C

🔌 Connectivity

  • RF Ports: 2x SMA connectors
  • USB: USB 3.0 Type-B
  • GPIO: 8x GPIO pins
  • Clock: Internal/external reference
  • Antenna: 50Ω impedance
  • Shielding: RF shielded enclosure
  • LEDs: Status indicators

⚡ Performance Features

  • ADC Resolution: 12-bit
  • DAC Resolution: 12-bit
  • Sample Rate: Up to 40 MSPS
  • Latency: Low latency operation
  • Jitter: < 1ps RMS
  • Phase Noise: Excellent
  • Spurious: Low spurious emissions

✅ Advantages

  • USB powered - no external supply needed
  • Compact and portable design
  • Cost-effective for most applications
  • Excellent for IoT security testing
  • Good performance for GSM/NB-IoT
  • Easy to integrate with Raspberry Pi
  • Low power consumption

❌ Limitations

  • Limited to 40MHz bandwidth
  • No external power option
  • Smaller form factor limits cooling
  • May not handle high-power applications
  • Limited GPIO compared to x40/x115
  • Single RF chain (no MIMO)

⚡ BladeRF x40 (Alternative)

📊 Technical Specifications

  • Frequency Range: 70MHz - 6GHz
  • Bandwidth: 40MHz instantaneous
  • Interface: USB 3.0 SuperSpeed
  • Power: External 12V/2A supply
  • Size: 120mm x 80mm x 20mm
  • Weight: 200g
  • Operating Temperature: -10°C to +70°C

🔌 Enhanced Features

  • RF Ports: 2x SMA connectors
  • GPIO: 16x GPIO pins
  • Clock: Internal/external reference
  • Power: External power connector
  • Cooling: Better thermal management
  • Shielding: Enhanced RF shielding
  • Status: Multiple status LEDs

🎯 Use Cases

  • Professional security testing
  • Research and development
  • Educational applications
  • Commercial deployments
  • Long-term monitoring
  • High-reliability applications
  • Laboratory environments

✅ Advantages

  • External power for stable operation
  • Better thermal management
  • More GPIO pins available
  • Enhanced RF performance
  • Professional-grade construction
  • Better for continuous operation
  • More robust design

❌ Limitations

  • Requires external power supply
  • Larger and heavier
  • Higher cost than Mini A4
  • Less portable
  • Still limited to 40MHz bandwidth
  • More complex setup

🚀 BladeRF x115 (High-End)

📊 Technical Specifications

  • Frequency Range: 70MHz - 6GHz
  • Bandwidth: 115MHz instantaneous
  • Interface: USB 3.0 SuperSpeed
  • Power: External 12V/3A supply
  • Size: 150mm x 100mm x 25mm
  • Weight: 400g
  • Operating Temperature: -10°C to +70°C

🔌 Advanced Features

  • RF Ports: 2x SMA connectors
  • GPIO: 32x GPIO pins
  • Clock: High-precision reference
  • Power: High-power external supply
  • Cooling: Active cooling system
  • Shielding: Military-grade shielding
  • Status: Comprehensive status display

🎯 Advanced Applications

  • Advanced research projects
  • Military and defense applications
  • High-bandwidth signal analysis
  • Multi-channel operations
  • Professional RF testing
  • Spectrum monitoring
  • Signal intelligence

✅ Advantages

  • Wide 115MHz bandwidth
  • High-performance RF chain
  • Extensive GPIO capabilities
  • Professional-grade construction
  • Excellent for wideband analysis
  • High-precision clock reference
  • Military-grade reliability

❌ Limitations

  • High cost ($800-1000)
  • Large and heavy form factor
  • Requires high-power supply
  • Overkill for basic IoT testing
  • Complex setup and configuration
  • Not suitable for portable use

🔄 Alternative SDR Options

📻 RTL-SDR

  • Frequency: 24MHz - 1.7GHz
  • Bandwidth: 2.4MHz
  • Price: $20-50
  • Use Case: Basic monitoring
  • Limitations: Receive only, limited bandwidth

📶 LimeSDR Mini

  • Frequency: 10MHz - 3.8GHz
  • Bandwidth: 30.72MHz
  • Price: $200-300
  • Use Case: Compact research & development
  • Limitations: Lower bandwidth than full LimeSDR

📡 USRP B200mini

  • Frequency: 70MHz - 6GHz
  • Bandwidth: 56MHz
  • Price: $700-900
  • Use Case: Professional research
  • Limitations: High cost, complex software

📶 LimeSDR Mini (Compact Alternative)

📊 Technical Specifications

  • Frequency Range: 10MHz - 3.8GHz
  • Bandwidth: 30.72MHz instantaneous
  • Interface: USB 3.0 Type-A
  • Power: USB powered (5V/1.5A)
  • Size: 69mm x 31.4mm x 8mm
  • Weight: 20g
  • Operating Temperature: -10°C to +70°C

🔌 Connectivity

  • RF Ports: 2x uFL connectors
  • USB: USB 3.0 Type-A connector
  • GPIO: 12x GPIO pins (0.05" pitch)
  • Clock: Internal VCTCXO + external ref
  • Antenna: 50Ω impedance
  • LEDs: Power and activity indicators
  • JTAG: On-board JTAG header

⚡ Performance Features

  • ADC Resolution: 12-bit
  • DAC Resolution: 12-bit
  • Sample Rate: Up to 30.72 MSPS
  • Duplex: Full-duplex (simultaneous TX/RX)
  • MIMO: 2x2 MIMO support
  • Phase Noise: -100 dBc/Hz @ 10kHz
  • FPGA: Intel Altera MAX 10

✅ Advantages

  • Extremely compact and lightweight
  • USB powered - no external supply needed
  • Full-duplex operation (TX + RX)
  • Wide frequency coverage (10MHz - 3.8GHz)
  • 2x2 MIMO capabilities
  • Open-source software ecosystem
  • Cost-effective for research applications
  • Strong community support

❌ Limitations

  • Limited to 30.72MHz bandwidth
  • Smaller FPGA compared to full LimeSDR
  • uFL connectors require adapters
  • Less TX power than BladeRF
  • May require manual driver installation
  • Setup can be more complex for beginners
  • Limited commercial support

🔄 YateBTS Compatibility with LimeSDR Mini

Feature Compatibility Configuration Required Notes
GSM 900MHz ✅ Full Support Frequency calibration Excellent performance
GSM 1800MHz ✅ Full Support Frequency calibration Good performance
NB-IoT Testing ✅ Full Support Bandwidth settings Requires SoapySDR
YateBTS Integration ⚠️ Manual Setup Driver installation Requires LimeSuite
Web Interface ✅ Full Support Device selection Works after setup

🎯 Selection Guide

🎯 Choose BladeRF Mini A4 If:

  • You need portable IoT security testing
  • Cost is a primary consideration
  • You want USB-powered operation
  • You're building a portable BTS
  • You need good GSM/NB-IoT performance
  • You want easy Raspberry Pi integration
  • You're starting with SDR development

⚡ Choose BladeRF x40 If:

  • You need professional-grade reliability
  • You're doing continuous monitoring
  • You need more GPIO pins
  • You want better thermal management
  • You're building a fixed installation
  • You need enhanced RF performance
  • You're doing commercial deployments

🚀 Choose BladeRF x115 If:

  • You need wide bandwidth (115MHz)
  • You're doing advanced research
  • You need maximum RF performance
  • You're doing signal intelligence work
  • You need extensive GPIO capabilities
  • You're building a laboratory setup
  • Cost is not a primary concern

📶 Choose LimeSDR Mini If:

  • You need ultra-compact form factor
  • You want full-duplex capabilities
  • You're doing research and development
  • You need MIMO functionality
  • You prefer open-source SDR ecosystem
  • You want wide frequency coverage
  • You're comfortable with manual setup

💰 Cost-Benefit Analysis

SDR Device Price Range Performance Portability Best For
BladeRF Mini A4 $200-250 Good Excellent IoT Security Testing
BladeRF x40 $400-500 Very Good Good Professional Testing
BladeRF x115 $800-1000 Excellent Fair Advanced Research
LimeSDR Mini $200-300 Excellent Good Research & Development

🚀 Ready to Choose Your SDR?

Get started with the perfect SDR device for your IoT security testing needs

📋 Hardware Guide 📖 Installation Guide 💬 Community Support